← All Briefings

Nonprofit Directors and Officers Coverage During Financial Distress in 2026

The policy is tested hardest when the money runs short. Most nonprofit boards buy directors and officers coverage to protect against the familiar exposures — an employment claim, a governance dispute, an allegation of mismanagement. Those exposures are real. But the moment a D&O policy is tested hardest is the one boards plan for least: when the organization itself runs out of money. In 2026, with funding pressure building across the sector, that is no longer a remote scenario.

The pressure is structural. Business bankruptcy filings reached 23,043 in the twelve months ending June 30, 2025, a 4.5 percent year-over-year increase that pushed total filings above even pandemic-era levels. Chapter 11 reorganizations ran to 8,408 filings, 11 percent higher than in 2020. The drivers named by analysts — higher interest rates, tightened credit, refinancing obstacles, and reduced government spending — fall hard on nonprofits, which often operate on thin reserves and depend on grants and government contracts that can be cut or delayed with little warning. An organization that loses a major funding stream mid-year does not have the luxury of a slow adjustment. It faces a solvency question, and the board faces a liability question at the same moment.

Distress does not simply mean less money — it is a different legal environment. As an organization approaches insolvency, the fiduciary duties of its directors begin to shift toward creditors, not only the mission and its donors. Decisions that were ordinary governance in a healthy year — which vendors to pay, whether to keep operating, how to wind down a program — become potential claims: breach of fiduciary duty, deepening insolvency, preferential payments, misrepresentation to lenders. Creditors, former employees, and bankruptcy trustees all become potential claimants. The claims rise exactly when the organization has the fewest resources to defend its leaders.

Here is the trap inside a standard policy. A standard D&O policy — a combined Side A, B, and C program — insures both the individual directors and the organization. In a bankruptcy, that creates a conflict. Because the policy also covers the entity, its proceeds can be treated as property of the bankruptcy estate, subject to the automatic stay under Section 362 of the Bankruptcy Code. The practical effect is severe: the directors who most need the policy to fund their defense may be blocked from reaching it, or forced to litigate for access, precisely when the claims are landing.

Side A coverage is the answer, and it is different in kind. A dedicated Side A policy covers only the individuals, not the entity, when the organization cannot or will not indemnify them. Because it does not insure the organization, its proceeds are far less likely to be pulled into the bankruptcy estate. Courts have reinforced the distinction — in the 2025 In re First Brands Group proceedings, a court was willing to lift the automatic stay for Side A access while restricting access to the combined policy. For a nonprofit board, the lesson is direct: in the scenario that matters most, Side A limits may be the only limits a director can actually reach.

A distress-ready program is built while the organization is healthy. Coverage bought under distress is coverage bought on the worst possible terms. A distress-ready D&O program carries adequate Side A limits, often through a dedicated Side A difference-in-conditions policy that sits above the main program and responds when the underlying coverage is unavailable. It is read for the insured-versus-insured exclusion and the bankruptcy and insolvency exclusions that some policies carry — provisions that can quietly gut coverage in exactly the scenario where it is needed. And it is paired with the governance discipline — documented board minutes, conflict management, financial oversight — that keeps the underwriter willing to renew.

This is the work PFTN brings to a nonprofit board. Strategic Discovery surfaces the organization's real funding concentration and the exposures a disruption would create. Risk Assessment quantifies what an insolvency scenario would mean for the directors personally and whether the current program would actually respond. Solution Design structures the Side A limits, the exclusionary language, and the program architecture so the coverage holds when the entity cannot indemnify. Ongoing Optimization revisits the program as the funding environment and the board both change.

No board wants to plan for the day the money runs short. But the directors who serve a mission deserve to know their personal exposure has been considered before that day arrives, not after. A grant can be cut, a contract can lapse, a reserve can thin faster than anyone projected — and none of those events should be the moment a board first learns how its own D&O program behaves in insolvency. The strongest governance decision a board can make in a hard funding year is a quiet one: confirm, while the organization is still sound, that the coverage protecting its own members would survive the organization's worst moment. That confirmation is not pessimism. It is the same fiduciary care the board already owes the mission, turned for a moment toward the people who carry it.

Sources: Willis Towers Watson — D&O Insurance and Distressed Risk: Is Your Program Bankruptcy Ready? (January 2026); The Baldwin Group — 2026 Nonprofit Mid-Year State of the Market; insura.ai — D&O Insurance for Nonprofits 2026: Board Liability Protection; Heffernan Insurance Brokers — Navigating Directors and Officers Insurance for Nonprofit Boards; The Coyle Group — What Nonprofit D&O Insurance Covers

— Ryan Mefford, President & Risk Advisor