← All Briefings

Excess and Umbrella Liability for Nonprofits in 2026

Most nonprofit leaders think about liability limits once a year, at renewal, and then rarely again. That is precisely the habit the 2026 casualty environment is built to punish. A single auto loss, a single abuse allegation, a single event gone wrong can now generate a demand that dwarfs the primary policy a board approved without a second glance. The question is no longer whether your general liability limit is adequate for an ordinary claim—it is whether anything stands behind that limit when the claim is extraordinary.

That is the work an excess or umbrella policy does. It sits above your underlying coverages and lends its limit when they are exhausted. In practice, a nonprofit umbrella typically drops over three towers at once: your commercial general liability, your business auto liability, and your employer's liability under workers' compensation. When a jury returns a number your primary carrier cannot reach, the umbrella is what separates a difficult year from a dissolved mission. It does not replace the underlying coverage—it extends it, and that distinction governs everything about how the policy should be built.

Why the pressure is building. The severity driving limits higher in 2026 is not imagined. Marathon Strategies found that corporate nuclear verdicts—awards of $10 million or more—reached a record $25.6 billion across 190 cases in 2025, a 40.7% jump over the prior year, with 40 "thermonuclear" verdicts exceeding $100 million apiece. Since 2020, the count of such verdicts has grown 476%. The forces behind those numbers are familiar to anyone reading the trade press: social inflation, jury pools increasingly inclined to punish institutions rather than merely compensate plaintiffs, and third-party litigation funding that bankrolls cases toward larger outcomes. Willis Towers Watson notes that tort costs are now growing at 8.7% a year, outpacing the broader economy.

Nonprofits are not spectators to this trend—they are squarely inside it. The exposures that feed a nonprofit umbrella are the very activities that define the work: volunteers and clients behind the wheel, premises open to the public, events that gather crowds, and, where it can still be purchased, abuse and molestation coverage. Gallagher's 2026 sector update reports nonprofit auto rates climbing 7% to 15%, with some claims exceeding $20 million in severity, and abuse coverage so constrained that fewer than five standard admitted carriers remain willing to write it for foster care and adoption providers. The umbrella is where these scattered exposures converge into a single, consequential limit.

Following-form versus standalone. Here the structure matters as much as the number. Most excess policies are "following form"—they adopt the terms, conditions, and exclusions of the underlying policy they sit over. That is clean and coherent, but it carries a hidden consequence: an exclusion buried in your primary general liability flows straight up into the excess. If abuse is sublimited or excluded below, following form does not cure it above. A standalone umbrella, by contrast, is its own contract with its own terms, which can broaden coverage—or, read carelessly, narrow it in ways the underlying never did. Neither is categorically better. What matters is that someone with fiduciary discipline reads both documents against each other and surfaces the gaps before a claim does.

The temptation, when it comes to the limit itself, is to default to a round number—a million, then another million stacked on top—because round numbers feel like decisions. They are not. An adequate limit is benchmarked, not guessed. It should be set against the organization's asset base and endowment, the scope and visibility of its mission, the size and use of its vehicle fleet, and the verdicts peer organizations in your jurisdiction and sector have actually faced. A social-service agency transporting vulnerable clients carries a different severity profile than a grantmaking foundation with no fleet, and their limits should look nothing alike. The right number uncovers your true exposure rather than flattering your budget.

The market itself is sending mixed signals, which makes the exercise both harder and more necessary. CRC's Q2 2026 excess and umbrella index shows rate increases decelerating to roughly 6% to 11%, down from the low-to-mid teens a year earlier, as fresh capacity competes for clean accounts. Yet capacity above the first $10 million remains genuinely scarce—RPS notes the lead layer now often takes multiple carriers to assemble what was once a single policy—and challenged classes, which many nonprofits are, see slower relief and tighter terms. Softer pricing is not the same as abundant coverage. The runway is open for well-documented, well-governed organizations; it narrows sharply for those who arrive at renewal with an incomplete story.

That story is the leverage. At Peoples First Tennessee, we build it through our 4-Step Strategic Process—Strategic Discovery to illuminate the mission and its real exposures, Risk Assessment to benchmark the limit against assets and peer verdicts, Solution Design to structure the tower and reconcile following-form against standalone, and Ongoing Optimization to keep the program aligned as the organization and the market both move. The limit above your limits is not a line item. It is the ownership you take of your mission's survival.

Sources: Nuclear Verdicts Against Companies Hit Record High in 2025, Topping $25.6 Billion; Nuclear Verdicts Go Boom, Increase 40.7% in 2025; Nonprofit Insurers Ease Some Rates While Abuse, Auto and Casualty Costs Keep Climbing; Insurance Marketplace Realities 2026 – Casualty; Excess + Umbrella REDY Index Q2 2026; US casualty market stabilizing after nearly five years of post-pandemic disruption – RPS

— Ryan Mefford, President & Risk Advisor