Premises and Products Liability for Nonprofit Thrift Stores and Social Enterprises in 2026
Across Tennessee, more nonprofit leaders are running what looks like a retail business alongside the mission. A thrift store on Clinton Highway, a donation center in Oak Ridge, a café staffed by program participants, a resale shop that funds a shelter — earned revenue has moved from a side project to a budget line the organization depends on. Candid reports that 71% of the aggregate revenue U.S. nonprofits report is earned income, and that about half of all nonprofits now report earning some. The pressure driving that shift is only building: the Georgia Center for Nonprofits found in March 2026 that 38% of organizations in its region lost government funding in 2025, and 28% expected further cuts in 2026.
Earned revenue is a disciplined response to that pressure. What often lags behind it is the insurance program — because selling goods to the public is commercial general liability and products liability exposure, and most nonprofit package policies were scoped for offices, programs, and volunteers, not a storefront.
The premises your customers walk into
A thrift store floor is a premises liability exposure in the most literal sense. Donated inventory arrives in waves, aisles get crowded, flooring wears, parking lots ice over, and the people browsing are legal invitees the organization owes a duty to keep reasonably safe. A customer who slips on a spill or trips over a misplaced box becomes a bodily injury claim — and those claims have grown more expensive. Verisk's 2025 analysis found general liability claim severity rose 45% between 2020 and 2024, from roughly $70,000 to $101,000 per claim, with bodily injury the main driver. Tennessee's modified comparative fault rule offers a partial check — a plaintiff who is 50% or more at fault recovers nothing — but that is a defense raised after a claim is filed, not a reason one will not be.
The goods on the shelf
Products liability is the exposure nonprofits rarely see coming. When an organization sells a used lamp, a space heater, a crib, or a toy, it has — in insurance terms — placed a product into commerce. The Consumer Product Safety Commission is direct that its safety laws apply to "anyone who sells or distributes consumer products," thrift stores and charities included, and that "used products have caused injuries and deaths and have been the subject of numerous recalls." A 2000 CPSC study cited by Nationwide found hazardous products in 69% of 301 thrift stores visited. Recalls are climbing — the CPSC logged more than 300 in 2023, up 20% from the prior year — and recalled items keep circulating through donation bins long after they leave store shelves.
Here is what makes resale different from ordinary retail. When a defective new product injures a buyer, the retailer can usually tender the claim up the chain to the manufacturer and its insurer. A donated, decades-old appliance has no such backstop — there may be no traceable manufacturer, no warranty, and no one left to indemnify. The nonprofit sits at the end of the chain and carries the risk itself. "As is" signage and staff screening are sound practices, and the discipline of monitoring recalls is worth building — but none of it transfers liability the way an indemnity agreement would.
Whether the policy actually responds
This is where the structure of a general liability policy matters. IRMI explains that the CGL separates two hazards. Premises and operations coverage responds to injuries at your location — the slip in the aisle. The products-completed operations hazard responds to injury that occurs away from your premises and arises out of "your product" — the heater that fails in a customer's home weeks later. These carry separate aggregate limits, and a policy written for a nonprofit that does not sell goods may exclude or sharply limit products-completed operations altogether. A donation bin in a leased parking lot, a café's food, a social enterprise's manufactured items — each can fall into a gap the original policy never contemplated.
The questions worth surfacing are concrete. Does your package policy include products-completed operations coverage, and at what limit? Does your classification on the policy reflect retail sales, or does it still describe you as an office-based charity? Who owns the donation bin and the parking lot exposure — the organization, or the landlord? Does an excess or umbrella layer sit above both the general and the products aggregates?
Bringing discipline to the exposure
This is the work our 4-Step Strategic Process is built for. Strategic Discovery surfaces every earned-revenue activity the organization now runs — the store, the bins, the café, the enterprise — and how each is described on the policy. Risk Assessment measures the premises and products exposure those activities create, including the recall and no-manufacturer gaps. Solution Design structures general liability, products-completed operations, and excess limits to the retail reality we uncover, rather than the office the policy once assumed. Ongoing Optimization revisits the program as the social enterprise grows and the claims environment shifts through 2026. The goal is ownership of the exposure — intentionally, before a customer's fall or a defective donation turns it into a claim.
Sources: Candid — "Earned income: A vital revenue source for nonprofits"; Georgia Center for Nonprofits — "Nonprofit Trends 2026: Why Revenue Diversification Can't Wait"; U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission — "Resale/Thrift Stores Information Center"; Nationwide — "Product liability prevention strategies for thrift stores"; IRMI — "The Hazards of Products and Completed Operations: Understanding the Fundamentals"; Stacker / Verisk — "The rising cost of slip-and-fall claims for US businesses"; Enjuris — "Tennessee Premises Liability Laws"
— Ryan Mefford, President & Risk Advisor