← All Briefings

Volunteer Injuries and the Workers Compensation Coverage Gap for Tennessee Nonprofits in 2026

Across Tennessee, nonprofits run on the labor of people who never appear on a payroll. Independent Sector now estimates the value of a single volunteer hour at $36.14 in 2026, and for a Knoxville food bank or Oak Ridge shelter that figure compounds into a second workforce. Yet the very trait that makes volunteers so valuable — that they serve without pay — is the trait that quietly removes them from the one protection every paid worker takes for granted. The gift of unpaid service carries a hidden exposure, and most boards never see it until someone is hurt.

Start with how Tennessee defines the people it protects. Under Tenn. Code Ann. Title 50, Chapter 6, an “employee” exists only where there is a contract of hire, an express or implied bargain to exchange labor for pay. A volunteer, by definition, makes no such bargain — she offers her time as a gift, not a transaction. Because workers' compensation attaches to the employment relationship and not to the act of working, the volunteer who twists a knee unloading a truck or slips on a wet church floor falls outside the system entirely. There is no claim to file, no benefit schedule, no medical coverage waiting to respond.

The consequence is a reversal most directors find counterintuitive. Workers' compensation is a bargain — the paid employee surrenders the right to sue in exchange for guaranteed, no-fault benefits. The volunteer surrendered nothing, so she keeps everything, including the right to walk into a courthouse. Where an injured employee is channeled into an administrative remedy, an injured volunteer is channeled toward your organization's liability policy and, if that policy is thin, toward your organization's balance sheet. The gap is not that volunteers are unprotected; it is that the nonprofit is exposed.

Here is where a widely trusted safeguard is widely misunderstood. The federal Volunteer Protection Act, 42 U.S.C. Ch. 139, does real work — it shields individual volunteers from personal liability for ordinary negligence committed within the scope of their service. But read the statute for what it does not say. It protects the volunteer, not the organization. The nonprofit itself remains fully answerable for its own negligence and for the acts of its volunteers under ordinary agency principles. The Act illuminates the volunteer's runway and leaves the entity standing in the same light it always did.

Closing the gap begins with coverage designed for the exposure rather than borrowed from another one. Volunteer and participant accident insurance responds to a volunteer's injury directly — it pays medical costs regardless of fault, which is precisely the point. It functions where workers' compensation cannot, giving the person who was hurt a first source of recovery and giving the organization a reason a lawsuit never needs to be filed. Carriers built for the sector, including the Nonprofits Insurance Alliance, structure this as an intentional line rather than an afterthought.

General liability is the second pillar, and structure is everything. A properly built commercial general liability policy should name volunteers as insureds, not merely employees, so that the person acting on your behalf is defended as though they were staff. Layered beneath it, medical-payments coverage responds to minor injuries promptly and without an admission of fault — a small, deliberate mechanism that resolves a scraped elbow before it hardens into a claim. The discipline is in the language of the policy, and that language is where uncovered volunteers hide.

Documentation converts good intentions into defensible practice. A signed waiver rarely bars a claim outright, yet a well-drafted acknowledgment of risk, paired with role descriptions and a record of orientation, does two things at once — it manages the volunteer's expectations and it demonstrates the organization's own diligence. As the Nonprofit Risk Management Center has long counseled, the goal is not paperwork for its own sake but a record that surfaces what everyone agreed to. The waiver you never needed is the one that quietly earned its place.

Two exposures deserve their own attention because they concentrate risk. Special events gather crowds, equipment, and untrained hands into a few high-energy hours, and the ordinary policy may not follow the volunteer to a rented fairground. Driving is the sharper edge — a volunteer running meals in a personal vehicle exposes both her auto policy and the nonprofit's, and hired-and-non-owned auto coverage is the bridge across that gap. The Nonprofit Risk Management Center flags volunteer drivers as among the most underestimated risks a mission-driven organization carries.

At Peoples First Tennessee, we work this problem through our 4-Step Strategic Process. Strategic Discovery uncovers where your volunteers actually serve and drive; Risk Assessment measures the gap between that reality and your current policies; Solution Design crafts the accident, liability & auto coverage that closes it; and Ongoing Optimization keeps the program current as your programs, events, and volunteer roster change. The point is ownership of the exposure, not reaction to it.

The people who give you their hours deserve an organization that has thought carefully about what happens if one is hurt. That is a fiduciary matter as much as a compassionate one — and it is within your control to address before, rather than after, the fact.

Sources: The University of Tennessee MTAS — Workers' Compensation Benefits for Volunteer Workers; Tennessee Code, Title 50, Chapter 6 (Justia); Independent Sector — 2026 Value of Volunteer Time ($36.14 per hour); U.S. House Office of the Law Revision Counsel — 42 U.S.C. Chapter 139, Volunteer Protection; Nonprofit Risk Management Center — Insurance for Volunteer Programs; Nonprofit Risk Management Center — Managing Volunteer Driver Exposures; Nonprofits Insurance Alliance — Volunteer / Participant Accident Coverage for Nonprofits

— Ryan Mefford, President & Risk Advisor